Short answer
On running cost, a good LED wins: top-tier fixtures test at 3 µmol/J or more against about 1.7 µmol/J for double-ended HPS [2][5][6], about 43 % less electricity for the same light. Budget panels can sit near 2.3 (about 25 % less); see the heat and power-bill myth and the LED buyer-beware guide. On quality per photon the GenetixBay answer is "perhaps", down for a Bay Trial. Contested (house position: open question).
Why
Photon quantity drives yield far more than colour; a lower blue fraction slightly raised yield, but efficacy mattered more for cost [1].
In a small, LED-maker-funded 2018 trial at about 450 µmol/m²/s, HPS gave more flower mass and LED higher THC and CBD concentration; total cannabinoid yield didn't differ [3].
HPS puts more radiant heat on the leaf; modelled LED leaves run about 1.3 °C cooler [4]. Every wall watt still becomes 3.412 BTU/h with either lamp.
The numbers
| White LED | HPS | |
|---|---|---|
| Efficacy (fixture) | ~1.8–3.7 µmol/J; ~6 % of DLC list at 3.0+ [6] | ~1.7 µmol/J double-ended [2][5] |
| Electricity for the same PPFD | ~25–45 % less, by fixture | baseline |
| Leaf temperature | ~1.3 °C cooler (modelled) | warmer [4] |
| Blue fraction | ~5–15 % typical | ~4 % [1] |
| Yield at equal PPFD | similar in most work | similar; more mass in one small trial [3] |
| Cannabinoid concentration | higher in one trial [3] | lower in that trial |
| Lamp replacement | none for years | bulbs lose output |
Verdict: pick a verified, efficient LED for cost and control; whether HPS buds are better per photon is unproven, so GenetixBay is testing it.
What to do
- Compare fixtures by µmol/J and PPFD map, not lamp type alone.
- Switching to LED? Raise air temperature 1–2 °C and re-check leaf VPD.
- Running HPS? Measure leaf temperature and cool to suit.
- Want to know for your cultivar? Run a side-by-side at the same PPFD and log grams and lab results.
Common mistakes
- Comparing an LED at 600 µmol/m²/s with HPS at 1,000.
- Keeping HPS room settings after switching to LED.
- Treating one manufacturer-funded trial as settled.
- Adding Cal-Mag "because it's LED" (Myth).
Related
- Full article: Light spectrum
- LED vs HPS: the heat and power-bill myth
- Samsung LM301B vs LM301H, bins and fake chips
- LED drivers explained
- Are purple (blurple) LEDs as good as white LEDs?
- Should I run my room warmer with LEDs?
- PPFD and DLI by stage
- Terms: LED vs HPS · Bay Trials