GenetixBayEST. 2009
Mythbusters · grow lore, checked

Grow lore, put on trial.

Every grow forum has its rituals. Here are the popular ones the evidence doesn't back, each with a verdict, the one-line reason, and the full article with its sources. Where nobody knows yet, it goes on the list of open trials instead.

154 myths busted12 open trialsEvery verdict cited
Professor Greenleaf with a magnifying glass

New to the jargon? The glossary defines 759 terms, from flushing to foxtails.

Greenleaf's standing challenge · unclaimed for 20+ years

Darkness before harvest? Show us the study.

Putting plants in 24–72 hours of darkness before the chop is a myth, and the founder's verdict is "complete and utter nonsense". Why switch off photosynthesis while the plant is still finishing its resin?

For more than 20 years they have offered a standing challenge: find a peer-reviewed study that shows a benefit (not a single-plant study, not biased or skewed) and a 50-pack of seeds is yours, no questions asked.

50seeds on offer20+years standing0claims so far
Read the ripeness evidence
Professor Greenleaf, unimpressed
The verdicts · 154 myths

Busted

Labelled Myth on the GenetixBay evidence ladder: widely believed, not supported by evidence. Follow a card to the article for the studies.

Headline myth · Genetics history

Myth: “Cannabis is much stronger than it was 20 (or 50) years ago”

Verdict: Busted. False as a claim about the genetics. Hashish, charas and sinsemilla traditions are centuries old and impossible with 5 % plants. The 'weak old weed' numbers measured seized, degraded, exported brick, not the best of what was grown

The evidence: Old cannabis wasn't weak: the "so much stronger than 20 years ago" myth →
Training

Myth: “Topping always increases yield”

Verdict: Busted. The only controlled cannabis study found yield gains from pruning on large greenhouse plants of one CBD-dominant cultivar; small indoor plants and other cultivars may respond differently, and some cultivars recover poorly from losing tips (grower-reported, GenetixBay)

The evidence: Topping vs LST: it depends on the cultivar, so test yours →
Pests

Myth: “Fungus gnats always mean you are overwatering”

Verdict: Inconclusive. Constantly wet media are the main driver, but microbially active media (compost, worm castings, kelp, blood meal) can produce 2-5 times as many gnats even when watering is reasonable

The evidence: Fungus gnats: the watering problem with wings →
Equipment

Myth: “LEDs cut your power bill in half”

Verdict: Busted. Only against old single-ended (mogul-base) HPS at about 1.0 µmol/J. Against double-ended HPS at about 1.7 µmol/J, a top-tier 3.0 µmol/J LED needs about 43% less power for the same light, a 2.5 µmol/J fixture about 32% less, and a mediocre panel far less

The evidence: LED vs HPS: the heat and power-bill myth →
Equipment

Myth: “LEDs give off less heat than HPS”

Verdict: Busted. Watt for watt, they give off the same: every electrical watt ends up as 3.412 BTU/h of heat in the room. An LED only puts in less heat when it draws fewer watts for the same light. It also moves the heat from the canopy (radiant) to the heatsink (convective)

The evidence: LED vs HPS: the heat and power-bill myth →
Equipment

Myth: “Samsung LM301H is a better chip than LM301B”

Verdict: Busted. In 2019, a Samsung LED sales representative told GenetixBay the two are identical parts sold with different datasheets (µmol for horticulture, lumens for lighting). The public datasheets show the same package, voltage bins, thermal resistance and flux bins. Bin, drive current and authenticity are what matter

The evidence: Samsung LM301B vs LM301H, bins and fake chips: an LED buyer-beware guide →
Hot topics · 20 debates

Hot topics

Not myths to bust, but arguments growers have every week. Here is what the evidence actually shows, and what GenetixBay does about it.

Germination

No weak light for seedlings: full light from the moment the cotyledons crack out

Seedlings under a dim 'starter' light for two weeks? We put them under near-full light the moment the cotyledons crack out, and average more than two weeks off the run. Here's the plant science behind it, and the one condition that makes it work: a root that never dries.

Read the evidence →
Environment

800 W in a 4×4 isn't overkill. For a PR run, it's underkill by a mile

800 W in a 4×4? Overkill? Not only is it not overkill: for a PR run it's underkill, by a mile. The plants were still gaining at 1,800 µmol/m²/s in the research; 800 W only gets a 4×4 to about 1,190. More light, more yield: the numbers, the PR zone, and the only two real downsides.

Read the evidence →
Environment

The flip isn't day 1 of flower: the 10–14 day transition and how to count it

Your breeder says 8 weeks, your plant takes 10. Nobody's lying: the clock usually starts at first pistils, not at the flip. The data on the 10–14 day transition, and how to count it.

Read the evidence →
Environment

UV-B for THC: marketing, not a potency tool. More light is all you need

UV-B bars promise more THC. Three controlled cannabis trials found nothing commercially useful, and the highest doses cut yield and terpenes. The same lab got 1.6 times the yield just by turning ordinary light up. More light is all you need.

Read the evidence →
Nutrients

Molasses and sugars for cannabis: microbe food, not plant food

Molasses for sweeter, bigger buds? The plant makes its own sugar in its leaves. Molasses feeds the microbes in the pot, which is fine in living soil and a risk in hydro. No sweeter buds, no extra yield: the science and the house position.

Read the evidence →
Nutrients

Organic vs synthetic nutrients: ions don't care where they come from

Organic weed tastes better? The roots take up the same nitrate, phosphate and potassium ions whether they came from compost or a salt bag; the plant can't tell the difference. No blind cannabis taste test has shown one. Ions don't care where they come from.

Read the evidence →
Nutrients

PK and "bloom boosters" for cannabis: mostly marketing, and what the trials show

Week 4, out comes the PK booster. Five controlled cannabis trials say the plant stopped wanting more phosphorus at about 25–60 mg/L, and extra potassium can lower cannabinoids. The bottle maths, the runoff, and why GenetixBay tapers nitrogen instead.

Read the evidence →
Systems

Let soil dry, hammer coco: why watering depends on the medium

'Let it dry out' and 'water it five times a day' are both right, in different pots. Soil needs to dry to breathe; coco breathes while wet and wants hammering with high-frequency fertigation. The root-zone oxygen and water-potential science behind both.

Read the evidence →
Training

12/12 from clone or seed: more harvests a year, and why we're a huge fan

Skip the veg, win the year. 12/12 from clone turns one room over about 4.5 times a year instead of 3, and we've seen 4+ oz per square foot from good clones dialled in. The harvests-per-year maths, the catch with seeds, and what 'dialled in' means.

Read the evidence →
Training

Topping vs LST: it depends on the cultivar, so test yours

Top it or tie it down? No study shows either wins, and after thousands of cultivars the response looks individual and genetic. The only way to know for your plant is a split-clone test. Here's how.

Read the evidence →
Diseases

Bottled microbes and additives: a fair tier list for cannabis growers

Bottled microbes: snake oil or root insurance? Within reason, some really do keep root rot away, just not the way the label says. A fair tier list, from the fungi that fight Pythium to the mycorrhizae that mostly don't take.

Read the evidence →
Harvest and cure

Irradiated cannabis: gamma, e-beam, X-ray, ozone, RF and what they do to your weed

A lot of legal flower gets zapped before it reaches the shelf. Most buyers are never told. Here's what gamma, e-beam, X-ray, ozone and RF actually do to terpenes, which places make anyone disclose it, and why growing your own skips the whole question.

Read the evidence →
Breeding

Breeders vs pollen chuckers: what real cannabis breeding looks like

Crossing two hype cuts and selling the seed untested isn't breeding. What a breeder actually does, with the arithmetic, and why it's the reason your 'feminised' pack hermed.

Read the evidence →
Breeding

Elite clone-only gatekeeping: why the classics live in a few hands

Some of the most important cuts in cannabis history survive in a handful of private gardens, swapped cut-for-cut or sold for thousands. Here is what the public record shows, and why GenetixBay exists to open it up.

Read the evidence →
Genetics history

Craft vs industrial cannabis: did legalisation's commercial model hurt quality?

We think the commercial legal model was the worst thing that happened to cannabis quality. Here is the case (recalls, irradiation, price collapse, small farms priced out) and what the data don't show.

Read the evidence →
Genetics history

Landrace hunting or biopiracy? Benefit-sharing, consent and cannabis

Nearly every modern line is built on farmers' selections, and almost none of them were ever asked, credited or paid. What the Nagoya Protocol requires, why cannabis falls through the cracks, and what fair landrace work looks like.

Read the evidence →
Genetics history

Patents and the gene pool: who can own a cannabis plant?

Cannabis plants, traits and methods can be patented, and some are. Here are the public records, the one notable court case, the legal debate about the commons, and why open documentation is the answer.

Read the evidence →
Genetics history

Same cut, a thousand names: renaming, relabelling and the shrinking gene pool

One state's medical lab records carried 637 strain names that boiled down to three chemical profiles. Genetic tests keep finding one plant under several names and several plants under one. Here's how renaming hides a shrinking gene pool.

Read the evidence →
Genetics history

Why everything tastes the same: the evidence that commercial cannabis is converging

Thousands of strain names, but most commercial flower falls into a handful of terpene groups, landraces are being hybridised away, and the market pays for THC. The data, and what we do about it.

Read the evidence →
Equipment

LED vs HPS: the heat and power-bill myth

"Half the power, half the heat." Not quite. Every watt you plug in still becomes 3.412 BTU/h of heat, LED or HPS. Here's the physics, the real µmol/J numbers, and the tricks that turn a '1000 W Samsung' panel into something much less.

Read the evidence →
Bay Trials · 12 open questions

Bay Trials: settle it once and for all

Some questions nobody has settled yet, including a few where the founder has a strong hunch (LED vs HPS, hydro vs living soil, autos vs their photoperiod sisters). GenetixBay members will run them as controlled side-by-sides: pre-registered hypothesis, matched clones or a split tent, weighed dry yield and lab results on both sides. Null results get published too.

Recruiting at launch

Tuck vs strip defoliation

Hypothesis
Tucking fan leaves gives equal or higher dry yield than stripping them, and stripping doesn't raise cannabinoid content.
Protocol
Matched clones, split tent: one side tucked only, one side defoliated at flip and day 21; same feed, light and dry.
Measures
Dry flower weight per plant, lab cannabinoids and terpenes, canopy PPFD map
Background: Defoliation and lollipopping: what to remove, when, and the evidence →
Recruiting at launch

13/11 vs 12/12, per cultivar

Hypothesis
Many cultivars flower fully on 13 h of light (with ramps), giving more total light and equal or higher yield than 12/12.
Protocol
Clones of one cultivar in two tents at the same PPFD; 13/11 vs 12/12 from flip to harvest; log days to finish.
Measures
Days to harvest, dry weight, lab cannabinoids, DLI from signed sensor logs
Background: Photoperiod and light leaks: 18/6, 12/12 and the dark period →
Recruiting at launch

Nitrogen taper vs full feed vs flush

Hypothesis
Tapering only nitrogen in late flower matches or beats a full feed, and both beat a pre-harvest water flush on yield and resin.
Protocol
Three matched-clone groups for the last 3 weeks: N taper (P, K, Ca, Mg, S and micros kept), full feed, plain-water flush.
Measures
Dry weight, lab cannabinoids and terpenes, blind smoke and smell panel, ash colour
Background: Pre-harvest flushing: a myth that costs you yield and resin →
Recruiting at launch

Humidity pack vs fresh bud vs nothing

Hypothesis
Two-way humidity packs don't preserve terpenes better than a well-cured jar with no pack, or one rescued with a fresh bud.
Protocol
One batch split into matched jars after the dry: pack, fresh-bud top-up, nothing; same storage, opened on the same schedule.
Measures
Water activity weekly, lab terpenes at week 0, 4 and 12, blind smell panel
Background: Curing and burping: jars, humidity and how long →
Recruiting at launch

Wet vs dry trim

Hypothesis
Wet and dry trim end with similar terpene content; dry trim loses slightly more trichome heads to handling.
Protocol
Branches from the same plants split at the chop: half trimmed wet then hung, half hung whole then trimmed dry.
Measures
Lab terpenes and cannabinoids, trichome loss (kief collected per gram trimmed), trim time per 100 g, blind smell panel
Background: Drying cannabis: the 60/60 method and water activity →
Recruiting at launch

Supercropping vs control

Hypothesis
Supercropping main branches in early stretch gives equal or better dry yield and bud quality than untrained branches.
Protocol
Matched clones; supercrop the top branches of half in week 1–2 of flower, leave the rest; same canopy height.
Measures
Dry weight, lab cannabinoids, bud density, photos at each stage
Background: HST and supercropping: controlled stem crushing →
Recruiting at launch

Mild late drought vs control

Hypothesis
A mild, controlled dry-back in the last week raises cannabinoid concentration in some cultivars without hurting yield.
Protocol
Matched clones; the treatment side is allowed to reach mild wilting before watering in the final 7–10 days; the control is watered normally.
Measures
Substrate moisture logs, dry weight, lab cannabinoids and terpenes, per-cultivar response
Background: Drooping cannabis: overwatering vs underwatering →
Recruiting at launch

Topping vs LST in autoflowers

Hypothesis
LST alone gives higher dry yield in autoflowers than topping, because any setback costs an auto time.
Protocol
Seeds from one auto line sown direct in final pots; topped once at node 4–5 vs LST only vs untrained.
Measures
Days to harvest, dry weight, plant height, photos weekly
Background: LST: low-stress training →
Recruiting at launch

Blind re-test: label vs independent lab

Hypothesis
Most retail flower labelled in the high 20s and 30s tests in the mid-teens to low 20s at an independent lab.
Protocol
Members buy flower legally, record the label, and send a coded sample to an independent lab; only aggregate statistics are published, never named businesses.
Measures
Label vs measured total THC and total cannabinoids, water activity at test, days since packaging
Background: Buyer beware: potency labels, strain names and other claims that don't hold up →
Recruiting at launch

LED vs HPS: terpenes, cannabinoids, blind taste

Hypothesis
At matched PPFD, DLI and canopy temperature, LED and HPS give equal cannabinoid content; any terpene or taste difference is small and comes from leaf and bud temperature, not the lamp type itself.
Protocol
Matched clones of one cultivar in two identical tents, one LED and one HPS, set to the same PPFD map and DLI; leaf-surface temperature and VPD matched with logged sensors; same feed, dry and cure. Swap the lamps between tents on the repeat run.
Measures
Dry weight per m² and per kWh, lab cannabinoids and terpenes, leaf and bud surface temperature, blind triangle taste and smell panel
Background: Light spectrum: blue, red, far-red and UV, what's real →
Recruiting at launch

Hydro vs living soil: the blind taste panel

Hypothesis
A well-grown hydro run matches a well-grown living-soil run on taste in a blind panel; any difference in terpene profile is small. The soil-symbiosis question stays open until the data say otherwise.
Protocol
Matched clones split between a recirculating hydro system and a living-soil bed in the same room, same light and climate; each side run by a grower experienced in that method; identical dry and cure; samples coded by a third member.
Measures
Lab terpene profile and cannabinoids, blind triangle test and preference panel, ash and burn notes, dry weight, root-zone microbiome sample (optional)
Background: Living soil (no-till, water-only organic growing) →
Recruiting at launch

Auto vs photo sisters: grams per m² per year

Hypothesis
Per square metre per year, an autoflower line out-yields its photoperiod sister unless the photoperiod side runs a dialled-in SOG or SCROG with a dedicated nursery; the photoperiod sister tests slightly higher in cannabinoids.
Protocol
An auto line and its photoperiod sister line from the same breeding project, in equal canopy areas for 12 months: autos sown direct in final pots back to back, photos run with a separate veg area counted in the footprint.
Measures
Dry grams per m² per year (nursery area included), grams per kWh, lab cannabinoids per harvest, days seed to harvest, losses and setbacks logged
Background: Photoperiod vs autoflower, and how autoflowering is inherited →

Want in? Join the waitlist and you'll hear when enrolment opens.

← All categories

Professor Greenleaf

Grow with the Professor.

The GenetixBay community is coming: honest grow journals, permanent GB-IDs for genetics, and a Professor who answers with citations. Founding Members get first access and a permanent badge.